Meet the flavors: the core classics, the rotating heartbreakers, and the dearly departed pints I still think about sometimes. Some are here for a long time, some are here for a good time, and some have gone to the great freezer case in the sky.

MY Flavors

Core Flavors

Rotating Flavors

Flavor Graveyard

Core Flavors

A cup of vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate and peanut butter chunk pieces on a blue background.

Buckeye Bawl

Go on, have a bawl 😭

Malted Vanilla Ice Cream + Peanut Butter & Chocolate Buckeye Ball Chunks

Ingredients: milk, cream, sugar, blue agave, peanut butter, chocolate, coconut oil, eggs, malted milk powder (contains wheat), salt, Madagascar vanilla, xanthan gum

A close-up of a cup of vanilla ice cream topped with rainbow sprinkles, a red gummy candy, and pink syrup, set against a blue background.

Circus Sadimals

The saddest show on earth 🎪

Birthday Cake Batter & Cream Cheese Frosting Ice Cream Swirl + Frosted Circus Animal Cookie Pieces + Rainbow Sprinkles

Ingredients: milk, cream, sugar, organic blue agave, circus animal cookies, rainbow sprinkles, eggs, cream cheese, cheesecake pudding, salt, natural flavor (birthday cake), lactic acid, xanthan gum

Close-up of a cup of cookies and cream ice cream with chocolate cookie chunks on a light blue background.

Dirty Earl

When life does you dirty, eat ice cream 🍦

Earl Grey Ice Cream + Oreo Cookies

Ingredients: milk, cream, sugar, Oreo cookies, organic blue agave, amaretto, eggs, salt, organic earl grey tea, xanthan gum

A close-up of a bowl of ice cream with pink and white swirls, topped with caramelized nuts, against a blue background.

Sadberry Pretzel Pie

For when you're berry de-pretz-ed 🥺

Raspberry Sherbet + White Chocolate Ice Cream+ Buttery Pretzel Pie Crumble

Ingredients: milk, cream, sugar, blue agave, raspberries, egg yolks, Ghirardelli white chocolate (contains soy), coconut oil, butter snap pretzels, flour, butter, salt, xanthan gum

Close-up of a creamy, light-colored frozen dairy treat topped with black pepper, in a white cup against a blue background.

Tahitian Vanilla Bean

Pure Tahitian Vanilla Bean ice cream made with homemade vanilla bean infused sugar and an abundance of hand-scraped vanilla bean seeds (over 3 whole beans per pint).

Ingredients: milk, cream, vanilla bean sugar, organic blue agave, eggs, salt, Tahitian vanilla beans, xanthan gum